What kind of papers can be adopted?The editor -in -chief of the core journal of media research says

Source | Publication Future

Why does your paper not be involved in repeatedly? What are the press releases of the core journal of media research? Let's see what the good papers in the eyes of the nine editors look like?

Chairman of China Press and Publication Media Group, President and editor -in -chief of "Publishing" Magazine Magazine

The good manuscript in my eyes

For more than 40 years, as the most authoritative academic journal in the industry, "Publishing in China" magazine has always insisted on selecting a manuscript, appointment, and posting a good manuscript. Combined with the practice of journals, there are three major characteristics in my good manuscript:

The first is to choose the topic. Academic articles are the most available to overwhelm the fried rice and chew others chewed. Therefore, the topic selection must be new, either you can ask new questions; or there is a new perspective of the old problem; or there is a new idea to solve the problem ... In short, when you look at the topic, it can make people refreshing, not the cloud.

The second is the deep content. Analysis of the problem should not be tasting. It must be comprehensive and profound. Three points into wood, whip in, cannot be said to everyone knows. You must have your own unique insights and unique views. Essence

The third is that the article must be real. There must be problems with the content of the topic, taking care of real problems, reflecting the value of research, and not studying for research; writing must also be simple and refined in writing. Make people Zhao Zhao.

"China Publishing" was published in January 1978. It was originally known as "Publishing Work". It was renamed "Published by China" in 1991. It was sponsored by the State Press and Publication Department and sponsored by China Press and Publication Media Group. Since the initiative, the magazine has always maintained the three major core journals of CSSCI source journals, Chinese core journals, and core journals of Chinese humanities and social sciences. It is an important reproduction source of "Xinhua Digest" and the National People's Congress "Copy Newspaper Information".

"Media" magazine president and editor -in -chief, Yang Chiyuan, secretary general of the Chinese Media Conference

The good manuscript in my eyes

In the long -term editorial practice, I feel that there are too few good manuscripts. Among the nearly 2,000 manuscripts I have reviewed each year, the proportion can be called a good manuscript. I think the good manuscript must have the following characteristics:

The first is the high value selection value. The topic selection should track and study the cutting -edge and hot issues of the development of the media industry, which has theoretical value and practical significance for the development of the media industry. Its importance right accounts for 25%.

The second is strong innovation. The perspective, research method, and content viewpoint must be innovative, and can summarize the actual work and rise to a certain height theoretical understanding. Its importance right accounts for 30%.

The third is to demonstrate strong logic. The argument has a solid theoretical basis, with clear logic, and correct views and conclusions. Its importance rights accounted for 15%.

The fourth is accurate arguments. The quoted data is authoritative, accurate, and comprehensive, with first -hand materials, and the arguments are appropriate. Its importance right accounts for 20%.

Fifth, the expression is clear. The foundation of a good papers should be clear, smooth, and write specifications. Its importance right accounts for 10%.

"Media" magazine is a national authoritative industry journal, a national authoritative industry journal, the core journal of Peking University, and the source of the CSSCI (expanded version) source journal, which was launched in 1999. It was originally known as "Newspaper Management" in 1999. Named "Media" year.

Editor -in -chief of "News and Communication Research", researcher of the Institute of Journalism and Communication of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, Zhu Hongjun, chief expert of the National Social Science Fund major project

The good manuscript in my eyes

I have entered the journal industry in the news communication semester for a full ten years. In the early days, I served a journal that focused on the development of the news communication industry. It has worked in the "Research on News and Communication" from 2013.

The good academic papers in my eyes should have at least three aspects:

First of all, the intention of "standing the sky". Taking the academic papers of news communication as an example, the so -called "top sky" refers to the theoretical response. Academic papers produce the content of the pyramid tower spire of human knowledge, the theory belongs to this part. The so -called "standing ground" means being able to take care of social reality. Journalism and communication research is more of social science research, and solving social reality problems. This is a natural mission of social science research.

Secondly, the point of view is "clear and new." Since it is a thesis, it should be the "point" of theory and make readers clearly perceive; since it is an academic papers, then "innovation" is the value of its value. It should be able to let the academic peers read in front of the eyes and quench thirst.

Finally, "scientific norms" in the argument. "Academic arguments are also an academic corruption," which has become the consensus of our academic community. No matter how high the idea, no matter how refreshing, there is no scientific and standardized argument, that everything returns to zero, and even harm to society.

"Research on News and Communication" is an authoritative academic journal of Chinese Journalism and Communication. The competent unit is the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences and the organizer is the Institute of Journalism and Communication of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences. The journal was founded in 1994, the first quarterly, changed to two -monthly in 2008, and in 2013 to monthly magazine. His predecessor "News Research Data" is an authoritative publication in the Chinese journalism history.

President and editor -in -chief of "Friends of Edit" Magazine Society Kang Hong

The good manuscript in my eyes

The manuscript is with the times and follows the times. Through the publication, all the attention of the publishing industry since the reform and opening up can find the ins and outs of the dragon. The theory of that year may be tangible or trace today; the forecast that year may be fulfilled or misplaced. There is no shortage of manuscripts in the publication, but the manuscript is always missing. As long as a woman's wardrobe is always missing, there will be one less in the editor's computer. The author changes, the manuscript changes, and the editor's idea of ​​the publication changes. Edit's high eyes, because of the eye -catching manuscripts, good manuscripts to achieve authors, readers, naturally achieve editors, and achieve publications. The law is abnormal, the potential is not settled, the soldiers are not normal, the water is not constant, and the manuscript looks like a good manuscript. If it can be clearly described, it is difficult to find a good manuscript "Editor's Friends" founded in 1981. At the beginning of the pioneering, it was "Friends of Editing". In 1985, it was officially renamed "Friends of Editor". Academic journals are the foundation for editing and publishing theory and theoretical systems. In 2009, it was awarded the title of "60 -year Influential Journal of New China" by the China Journal Association, becoming the only journal in the country's publishing industry, and the only magazine in Shanxi Province to receive this award; Journal, National Library Key Press; since 1992, it has been rated as a first -level journal in Shanxi Province for 20 consecutive years. Publishing core journals. "Friends of the Editor" is one of the few three -core journals in Shanxi Province, and is the core journal of Peking University, NTU, and the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.

Editor -in -chief of the Journal of News, Senior Editor, Ph.D. in Journalism, and Part -time Master of Journalism of Fudan University Liu Peng

The good manuscript in my eyes

In recent years, the "Journalist" magazine highlights the academic and standardized thesis published, avoid general business experience introduction or news phenomenon review articles, and comprehensively adopts an anonymous review of experts to ensure the quality of thesis. At the same time, we advocate academic research with awareness and practical care to avoid pretending to pretend to be high but lack of academic insights. We continue to maintain the cutting -edge of the topic selection, adhere to the keen (topic selection), sharp (perspective), emerging (style) manuscript selection and journal style, and more around the new development environment, media formats, and news communication theory Change planning topic. Since 2019, "Journalists" will work hard around the improvement of service quality. Hope to get the support of more readers.

"Journalist" was founded in 1983. Adhering to the principle of advancing with the times, follow the guidelines for journalists, help journalists, serve the journalists, and help journalists. Enhance communication, let the circle outsiders understand reporters, and make it a university that cultivates journalists and a large family who attract readers inside and outside the circle.

Su Lei, editor -in -chief of Tsinghua University Press "Technology and Publishing" magazine

The good manuscript in my eyes

The qualified papers in my mind should meet the requirements of 5 aspects--

1. The orientation is correct. The full text should be guided by the correct orientation, and adhere to the correct political orientation, content orientation, and value -oriented, which is the most fundamental requirement for the quality of academic papers.

2. Innovation of topic selection. New opinions and opinions on publicity of publicity, new opinions and new opinions, service scientific and technological progress and promoting scientific and technological innovation should be the starting point for writing academic papers. Innovation is the value of academic papers.

3. The logic is complete. On the basis of innovation, the full text should be focused, logic should be strict, and it can withstand scrutiny. The writing of academic papers is mostly based on "finding problems -analysis of problems -solving problems" as the logical architecture. The logical dimension should be unified to avoid leakage. Science is the life of academic papers.

4. The content is practical. The author's research should originate from practical problems. The problem orientation should be the power source of creation. Countermeasures to solve problems should be operable and can promote the development of productivity. Practicality is the fundamental significance of academic research.

5. Wen Congzun. On the basis of logical rigorous, the language should be simple and smooth. "True Buddha only speaks of home", while pursuing academicity, the article should also take into account both. Readability is the key factor in measurement of the quality of academic papers.

"Science and Technology and Publishing" was founded in 1982, monthly magazine, director of Tsinghua University, sponsored by Tsinghua University Press, academic instructor of the Chinese Edition Association Science and Technology Publishing Committee, is the source of Chinese social science quotes (CSSCI) source journals, Chinese core journals, "copy newspapers and magazines "Data" important reprint source journals, China Humanities and Social Sciences (CASS) core journals, which have been included and published by many domestic authoritative literature retrieval agencies

Zhang Jing, senior editor of Henan Daily Newspaper Group and President of "News Lovers" magazine

The good manuscript in my eyes

A good academic article In addition to the correct views, strong arguments, sufficient arguments, strict logic, and smooth sentences, such as the basic requirements of the article, we must also have the "five new": new topic, new viewpoints, new angles, new angles The method is new and the materials are new. This "five new" is also the requirements of our "News Lovers" magazine in recent years.

New topic. The first is that the topic must be "pretty" and "bright", which can attract readers' attention, grasp the reader's psychology, and guide readers to read; the second is to fit the new era. Whether it is ancient or today, it must be associated with the actual actual situation, solve practical problems, and has guidance, reference, and revelation of reality. After the selection of topics was selected, most of the article was successful. New point of view. Just don't make old bombs, stand at the forefront of academics, put forward new views and explain new opinions.

New angle. That is, the incision should be small, accurate, clever, and tricky.

New method. It is to use new methods to solve new problems. Don't eight essays.

New materials. It is original, do not copy and paste.

"News Lovers" is the only journalist magazine published in Henan Province. Since its inception in 1986, it has won the Henan Provincial Excellent Journal Nomination Award and Excellent Section Setting Award. It has been repeatedly rated as the provincial first -level journal. Seventh and eighth news core journals.

Zhao Jin, deputy editor of "Youth Reporter" magazine

The good manuscript in my eyes

The direction of "Youth Reporter" is to be an advocate of advanced media culture and build a media research authority. The selection of articles pays more attention to the following aspects:

First, the author must have a certain grasp of the research progress and development trends involved.

Second, the article should be self -disciplined, and it is rational and constructive, which is conducive to the progress of academic research and industry practice.

Third, the practicality of news communication is very strong. I hope that the article has a standardized theoretical explanation and construction, and there must be a practical level of advice and appeal. "Problem" is a point we attach great importance to it.

Fourth, advocate improvement of the style of improvement, and encourage articles that are moderate and smooth in space.

Of course, if the article can be forward -looking, it reflects keen observation and academic accumulation; it can absorb theoretical resources of different disciplines, innovate news communication research methods, and even provide academic explanations and practical guidance for social development from a professional perspective. That's the good text that can't be asked.

Because of looking forward to and hoping to promote the "Chuangfeng Qing Yu Lao Feng Sheng", "Young Journalist" has a layout for young teachers and graduate students at school, and specially opened up the "Green Pepper Forum" and on the WeChat public account "Young Reporter" The "Qingyin Yuan Broadcast" column, welcome everyone to submit.

"Youth Reporter" magazine, founded in 1942, was sponsored by Volkswagen Newspaper Group (Volkswagen Daily), Shandong Journalists Association, Shandong Provincial Journalism Society. Social science journal AMI comprehensive evaluation expansion journal. Won the 2nd and 3rd Shandong Press and Publication Awards; the 2019 China Journal Association awarded the honorary title of "70 years of paying tribute to innovation".

Editor -in -chief of "Publishing Wide Horn" Zhu Jingwei

The good manuscript in my eyes

The press and publication industry in the new era is very promising, providing a good atmosphere for the academic research of the prosperous industry. Good articles are scientific, objective, comprehensive, and fair. They are based on the actual development of the industry. It meets the development needs of the new era and can provide warm academic nourishment for the development of the industry. They originated from the original intention of workers and practitioners in the press and publication industry, explore the laws of industry development that conform to China's national conditions, summarize the development of the industry's development and experience, objectively and comprehensively think about the challenges encountered in the development of the industry, propose scientific, appropriate rationalization It is recommended that it can provide academic support and academic nourishment for the development of the industry. They represent the responsibility of the majority of news publishers, adherence to, aggressive, and cautiously, and promote the academic innovation, academic exchanges, and academic accumulation of the industry. The consideration of one word and one punctuation is the ingenuity of the scholars' ingenuity. Their crafted articles made us feel and proud; the hard work they paid for these academic achievements made us deeply admire.

"Publishing Wide Horn" magazine was published in 1995 and was a professional academic journal in the Chinese press and publication industry. Head of Guangxi Normal University, hosted by Guangxi Journal Media Group Co., Ltd. The magazine was rated as a key social science journal of the Second National Journal Award, "China's Most Beautiful Journal", and was selected as "National Core Journal of Chinese", Chinese Social Science Citation Index (CSSCI) (Extended Edition) source journals and photocopy newspapers. Source journal.

This article is reproduced from the WeChat public account "Journal Power"

- END -