After the medical treatment, the patient said that it was forced to pay the fee on the spot by 120, which caused the injury to "worsen the snow". The court sentenced

120 ambulances need to be charged

So when should patients pay?

Recently, Mr. Li in Shanghai

Because of the charging problem with 120

A lawsuit with an emergency center

He said, 120 emergency personnel

Pushing it for the act of paying the fare

As a result, the injury of his original fracture "worsen the snow"

Calculating 10,000 yuan to the emergency center and asking for apology

Disputes of 120 fares for car accidents due to car accidents

Morning on May 8, 2021

Mr. Li passes through Shanghai Pudong New District

Traffic accidents occur during Lianzhong Road

Causes him to fall to the ground

Separation and dizziness and weakness

After the enthusiastic passersby discovered the situation

Dial 120 emergency calls in time

120 ambulances after the field

Take him away from the scene and send it to the hospital for rescue

Mr. Li recalled that due to the sudden incident of a car accident that day, he was not accompanied by his family members during the 120 transfer. After the emergency vehicle arrived at the hospital, before the inspection was completed and the report results had not yet come out, the staff of the 120 emergency vehicle stopped with the police and asked him to pay the fare and medical expenses.

Mr. Li said: "I asked them to wait for their parents, or to pay the money when my colleagues came, but 120 still did not depend on the same, forcibly asked for money on the spot." After opening the bag with both hands to pick up the wallet, it was allowed to be released after paying 156 yuan.

What makes Mr. Li cannot understand that the hospital has opened a green first -aid passage. If the medical expenses are not paid, the doctor will start a CT and other inspection items. "Board".

The subsequent CT examination results showed that Mr. Li's right humerus nodule fracture was accompanied by multiple trauma. After Mr. Li's family went to the hospital, he paid the medical expenses in the green first -aid passage without paying the medical expenses. At the same time, the doctor stated in Mr. Li's medical record that fractures need to be braked (Note: fracture braking finger bones are broken, you need to reduce activities and not exercise).

Mr. Li believes that the 120 emergency car is not a taxi outside. When the patient cannot determine whether his physical condition has the ability to pay, the staff of the first aid vehicle can contact the patients and units of the patients first to pay. Patients must settle money on the spot. Originally, he should brake it after the fracture was injured, but the emergency center still asked him to pay the fee, which caused his shoulder sleeve injury to worsen and further aggravated the injury. Then he made claims and apology to the emergency center.

120 emergency: no fault in charge

I feel very aggrieved in the emergency center involved

I think there is no fault in the behavior of their own fees

Do not agree with compensation and apology

Mr. Li's shoulder injury is completely due to the consequences of damage caused by traffic accidents, and there is no causal relationship with the charging behavior of the emergency center. Moreover, the emergency medical services of the emergency center are originally paid services. The emergency center cannot wait because Mr. Li does not pay the relevant costs, because during the waiting period, more patients who need emergency patients will have the requirements of the car.

In addition, when Mr. Li refused to pay the emergency fee on the same day, he said: "You must do inspections first and do not pay." He did not tell the emergency staff or colleagues to pay the fee after coming to the family or colleagues. The duty staff of the first aid center also asked him to pay the fee after Mr. Li completed the CT inspection, and he reported that he had not reported it after it was still unsuccessful. Under the intervention of the police, Mr. Li completed the fare payment.

Court: 120 Requires the payment fee to not infringement

After hearing of the Pudong New District Court of Shanghai, he pointed out

In this case, in the hospital

After the doctor in the emergency room is handed over

The emergency service work of the emergency center has ended

Mr. Li should pay the corresponding ambulance service fee

Mr. Li failed to provide evidence to prove that he had asked his family and colleagues to pay the ambulance fee, and failed to provide sufficient evidence to prove that the action of paying money and payment caused his injuries to further expand, so the court was difficult to adopt the letter.

Moreover, Mr. Li's injury was fractures on the right humerus nodule and multiple soft tissues. However, Mr. Li's left hand was not injured, and his basic life signs were smooth and clear. After the emergency centers, the inspection is over, and then the police handle the payment of ambulances through the police, in line with the work operation process.

finally

The court asked Mr. Li to ask for an emergency center

The request for compensation and apology will not be supported

Some netizens believe that patients should pay the ambulance in time

Some netizens believe that 120 needs to improve the fees system

Considering the patient's situation

Some netizens reminded the medical insurance card to pay

What do you think?

Xinmin Evening News (XMWB1929) Comprehensive Shanghai rule of law and netizens commented

Edit: Li Zheng

- END -