The "changes in the style of style" of procuratorial legal documents

Just to be realized, but also to be realized in a visible way. As a carrier of procuratorial cases, a paper prosecution legal document is a big deal.

"Can't stop in the notification of a result. Procuratorial legal documents must have user thinking and product awareness, and take the writing of procuratorial law documents as an important part of procuratorial cases, integrate this knowledge into 'blood', and develop a procuratorial legal document. The "muscle memory '." Recently, under the promotion of Wang Yong, deputy secretary of the party group of Suzhou Procuratorate in Jiangsu Province, Wang Yong, deputy secretary of the party group and deputy prosecutor of the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate, Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate regarded procuratorial legal documents as a prosecutor. The core ability has set off a journey of "writing and chewing words" for procuratorial legal documents.

Make a decision not to prosecute

Why isn't the complaint not satisfied?

"Thanks to the procuratorate's decision to make no prosecution, but I still have a few questions ..." I thought that the decision to get a decision was not prosecuted. Assistant Zhang Huimin realized that this paper procuratorial legal document did not meet the expectations of the parties.

One day in 2019, when Jin Liang and his girlfriend ate outside, he conflicted with Chen and Hao in his neighbors. In the fighting, Chen had a nasal bone injury. After identification, Chen Mou suffered a minor injury. Afterwards, the two parties reached an understanding agreement. Considering that the crime was lighter, the procuratorial organs finally made a decision to not prosecute Jin Liang.

"Chen has a fault first, and should be punished accordingly. It is not mentioned that the situation of the fight is neither mentioned nor the cause of the fight, so I am not satisfied." In this way, because of the dissatisfaction with legal documents, let the legal documents make Jin Liang became a complaint of criminal cases.

"I really did not expect that he would be so concerned about the details of the decision in the book." Zhang Huimin said, "We don't know, we use our own position to measure the needs of the parties and form formed After getting used to understanding, it automatically reduces the requirements of procuratorial legal documents. "Although Jin Liang finally accepted the decision after many communication, Zhang Huimin deeply realized that this paper legal document conveyed the organizer’s The idea and viewpoint of handling cases is an important channel for the parties to feel fairness and justice. The factual statements of legal documents are not comprehensive or the expression is easy to produce ambiguity, which will greatly affect the judicial credibility of the procuratorial organs.

"There are still many legal documents to send to investigating agencies, trial agencies, and administrative agencies. The reporter said.

Compared with legal documents, Wang Yong first focused on the indictment. The experience of engaging in prosecution for many years has made Wang Yong pay particular attention to the prosecution. "The indictment is the most basic and core legal document. It is the" facade of the procuratorial work '. "As early as June 2020, at the suggestion of Wang Yong, the Suzhou Procuratorate formulated and issued the" Suzhou Procuratorate Prosecutor's Prosecution Specifications specifications. Guide. Today, this specification has gone out of the Suzhou procuratorial organs and has become the public prosecution of the prosecutor of various places.

Shortly after working in the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate, Wang Yong read the prosecution of the hospital that month. "I have found a lot of problems. Some prosecutors have a lot of typos, and some sentences are not smooth. There is also an indictment. The official seal of the procuratorate is covered on the blank page. If this document is issued, the consequences are unimaginable."

To this end, Wang Yong decided that he had to look at all the prosecutions one by one. If there is a problem, Wang Yong will directly communicate with the organizer to promote the police's awareness of the quality of documents and improve the ability to write in the document. Under the promotion of Wang Yong, a selection plan for improving the ability of procuratorial legal documents has gradually formed. Considering the habit of their own people, this time, the hospital decided to hand over the "ruler" of the review to outsiders.

"Outer brain" scroll

Make a review opinion of nearly 20,000 words

How is a perfect procuratorial legal document?

From Wang Yong's view, from a professional perspective, it is necessary to use logical demonstration to promote the conclusion, but also from the perspective of the general public to respond to the attention of the parties and even the public. "The procuratorial legal documents should not be high and widow, but also take the mass line, so that the public can read it and understand it." Wang Yong said. Based on this consideration, Wang Yong invited many judges from political and legal institutions, trial agencies, judicial administrative agencies, and media units to enter the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate.

According to the plan, the three types of documents such as the decision decision, the reason for the reasons for arrest, and the supplementary investigation outline are the goals of the first selection. "These three types of documents are common legal documents in practice. Taking the decision of decision -making as an example, it directly affects the vital interests of the people involved and has attracted much attention from the society. In particular, in recent years, with the less arrest of princess criminal judicial policy, The implementation of the implementation of the criminal structure has shown a light torture trend, and the proportion of the decision decision decision is significantly increased. In practice, it also puts forward higher requirements. "Lu Weijiao, deputy prosecutor of the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate.

If the external effect is generated without prosecution decision, then the instructions of the reasons for not arrest and the complementary investigation outline will affect the internal efficiency of litigation within the political and legal agencies. "Such documents help to clarify further investigation directions and work points, and directly affect the quality and efficiency of criminal proceedings." Wang Yong said.

One week after submitting all the documents to the "external brain", the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate received the "reply" as scheduled. In Wang Yong's view, the problems discovered by "Readers" are universal -both include standardized expression, such as omitted necessary content, more verbal words, irregular documents, etc. Professional issues such as insufficient legal search; in terms of rationality, there are also problems such as insufficient argument, inadequate reasoning, lack of logical and excessive proof of different degrees of discussion. The comments of nearly 20,000 words of comments showing the "scrolls" group strength and group power, condensing the public's expectations of procuratorial legal documents. In the face of this 20,000 -word comments, especially those blunt flaws and problems, what is the mood of "contestants"? What will the prosecutor think of these opinions?

Update concept

Promote the "changes in style" of legal documents

"I wrote this document two years ago. Now I read it back. In some places, I can't understand it." The prosecutor of the five evil forces of criminal gangs who extorted and provoked the case.

"Write a good article to go through the three levels of rationality from the three levels of rationality. If the norms depend on the usual habit, the accurate attitude is to be accurate. Then, reasoning needs to be continuously studied and practiced. "Wang Yong told reporters that after the first selection, the affiliate and organizer attached more and more attention to the document. The irregularities and errors are getting less and less.

"Now the legal documents that need to be modified are significantly reduced. Some document formats and expressions involving simple crime cases have also formed a unified and standardized expression habits." Min Yali, director of the first procuratorial department of the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate, told reporters.

"We can deeply feel the huge changes in. When writing legal documents, we must not only export the viewer's point of view, but also stand from the perspective of the parties or even the public to examine this view. Can understand the case more comprehensive. "Li Hongwei, prosecutor Li Hongwei, prosecutor of the First Procuratorate of the Suzhou Industrial Park Procuratorate.

"The high requirements for the quality of the document can indeed force the prosecutor to fully check the facts." In Wang Yong's view, the facts of the case comprehensively include the facts of the case, but also include the facts of the sin, but also the cause of the matter, the degree of fault of the two parties, the degree of fault of the parties. The facts that affect the consideration of sentencing and the necessity of prosecution. In the past, because the procuratorial law was not deeply written, such facts were easily overlooked, which led to the discount on the effect of procuratorial cases.

"On the surface, it is a new requirement for the work of procuratorial legal documents, and it is fundamentally a new requirement for the concept of procuratorial case handling." Wang Yong introduced to reporters that now the police have changed from the concept and attach great importance to it. Although there will be a little discomfort in the process of transition, once the habit of regulating rigor is developed, the "muscle memory" is formed, which will benefit for life for prosecutors.

(Source: Procuratorate Author: Yu Xiao)

- END -