Multiple judgments show that women's public places are beaten in public places, drunk is not an

At 2:40 am on June 10, a barbecue restaurant in Tangshan City had a provocative trouble and violently beating others. After an initial investigation, the suspect Chen Mouzhi harassed and beat the other party, and then his colleagues beating the woman and her three female companions. On -site surveillance video showed that the means of beating are fierce, unscrupulous, and outrageous.

On the evening of June 10, the reporter retracted a number of related referee documents on the Chinese referee document network based on "women", "beating", "chatting", and "harassment".

Several women refused to talk about harassment and were beaten

The judgment of the People's Court of Luzhou District, Fuyang City, Anhui Province ([2019] Anhui 1202 China Early Chu No. 7444) shows that at 1:00 on April 26, 2019, Wu Xiaoyan (female) and friend Sun Jiaojiao and Zhao Juan were in Luzhou, Fuyang City. Quantong Yonghe Soymilk Store in Qinghe East Road in the district eats. Mena, who dine at the restaurant, came to Wu Xiaoyan and others to chat in front of the table. During the period, he conflicted with Sun Jiaojiao and assaulted Sun Jiaojiao. Wu Xiaoyan stepped forward to question, and was beaten by Gu Huaidong. On May 20, 2019, Gu Huaidong was punished for administrative detention for thirteen days and fined 500 yuan.

The People's Court of Yinzhou District made a judgment. Gu Huaidong compensated Wu Xiaoyan's economic losses of 7128.7 yuan, including reasonable economic losses was 5334.82 yuan for medical expenses, 1243.88 yuan (113.08 yuan/day × 11 days), and hospitalized food subsidy fees of 550 yuan. (50 yuan/day × 11 days).

Another similar case also happened in the early morning and the place was in the bar.

黑龙江省宝清县人民法院判决书（【2021】黑0523民初2152号）显示，2020年7月8日凌晨2时许，张甜甜（女）与杨苗苗到某私人订制酒吧喝酒时，与The man named Zhang Bin had a mouthful, and then Zhang Bin and his friend Gao Yan beat Zhang Tiantian and Yang Miao Miao with his fists. Then Zhang Tiantian grabbed Zhang Bin's peers from letting him leave, and was beaten by Zhang Bin's friend Song Xuemeng. Zhang Tiantian was hospitalized for 18 days after being injured.

Zhang Tiantian said that as soon as he entered the bar Zhang Bin, she talked to her and her friends. She ignored the room. Then the two sides had a mouthful, and Zhang Bin knocked it down from behind.

On July 14, 2020, the Baoqing County Public Security Bureau gave an administrative penalty of illegal actors Zhang Bin for 15 days and punished a fine of 1,000 yuan; illegal actor Gao Yan administrative detention for 10 days and 500 yuan of administrative penalties; Illegal actor Song Xuemeng's administrative fine of 500 yuan.

The People's Court of Baoqing County, Heilongjiang Province made a judgment. Zhang Tiantian had a total loss of 17677.17 yuan.

The reporter noticed that it was not uncommon for women to be beaten because of rejection of strange men.

The judgment letter of the People's Court of Xiangfang District, Harbin City, Heilongjiang Province ([2017] Hei 0110 Minchu 6211) shows that at 22:10 on August 21, 2017, Cui Fengrong (female) was taken by the man Song Yan on the way home. Cui Fengrong expressed his refusal to refuse After being scolded by Song Yan, he was beaten with his fist waiting for injuries.

After being diagnosed with Heilongjiang Provincial Hospital, Cui Fengrong's injury was mild closed craniocerebral injury, abdominal trauma, and left elbow skin scratch. The matter was processed by the Xincheng Police Station of the Xiangfang Branch of the Harbin Public Security Bureau.

The Xiangfang District People's Court made a judgment on the case. Song Yan needed to compensate Cui Fengrong's medical expenses of 6659.38 yuan; the food subsidy fee was 700 yuan; the misalignment fee was 2125.35 yuan; the transportation fee was 235.3 yuan.

Drunk is never an excuse to violate or insult

Through retrieval of referee documents, the reporter found that many men harassed and beat strange women after drinking.

Judgment of the People's Court of the Hengqin New District, Zhuhai Province ([2020] Guangdong 0491 China Early Chu No. 1215) shows that on the evening of May 9, 2020, Luo Huiyi (female) in a slope roast chicken shop in Xiangzhou District, Zhuhai City to eat dinner with her family with her family. , Drunk man Chen Ximing beaten for no reason. The Cuixiang Police Station of the Zhuhai Public Security Bureau was punished by Chen Ximing's administrative detention for 5 days.

Luo Huiyi said that at that time, she and her family had dinner. Chen Ximing came to talk and touched her shoulders with her hands. Her subconsciously threw off Chen Ximing's hand and used language to stop his rude behavior. Chen Ximing immediately hit his head and face with his fist. Essence When he was beaten, Luo Huiyi had a dizziness for a while, without any consciousness, and no resistance.

The court believes that after Luo Huiyi was beaten, he had symptoms such as tinnitus and dizziness from time to time. From the description, the injury was indeed worthy of sympathy. Luo Huiyi complained that the basis for compensation for the spirit damage was not supported. The final verdict was as follows: Chen Ximing compensated Luo Huiyi for the hospital for inspection fee of 562.3 yuan and apologized to Luo Huiyi in writing.

The judgment of the Panzhou People's Court of Guizhou Province ([2020] Guizhou O222 No. 6609) shows that at around 1:43 on May 23, 2020, the man Zhu Lei talked to the woman Shu Jing after wine, and then quarreled. Zhu Lei She held Shu Jing's hair and beaten her with her hands and feet, causing Shu Jing to be hospitalized for 30 days and paid 12089.29 yuan for medical expenses. Afterwards, Zhu Lei was detained by the public security organs for twelve days.

Zhu Lei's entrusted litigation agent argued that Shu Jing knew that Zhu Lei was still quarreling with him, and he had a major fault to cause his own damage. According to law, Zhu Lei's liability should be reduced.In this regard, the court stated that Shu Jing did not tolerate the legal obligations of Zhu Lei who tolerated drunk and insult. As a woman, Shu Jing encountered foreign violations and insults late at night to refuse and resist argument with Zhu Lei.Just as the court, the court resolutely supported its behavior.In the end, the court's judgment was as follows: Zhu Lei compensated Shu Jing's economic loss of 21949 yuan.

Source: Surging News

Edit: Weekend

- END -