The woman went to the colleague's house to pick pears and was injured, claiming 130,000 yuan!Court: "Family benefits, so rejection of demands"

Colleagues pick pears in their own house

An accident happened

Smilled by a pear

Who should be responsible for this

Related topics also rushed to the hot search list

Let's look at it together

My colleague's house was injured

Recently, Changsha, Hunan

Ms. Liu went to the orchard of my colleague Mr. Li's house to pick pears

Gels in advance

Mr. Li was not there that day

Mr. Li's wife, Ms. Huang, warmly received Ms. Liu

And take the initiative to take out the bamboo cricket to help Ms. Liu go to the orchard to fight pear

Just after Ms. Liu picked up the falling pear

A pear suddenly dropped on the tree

Just hit Ms. Liu's left eye

After going home

Ms. Liu feels that her left eye is getting more and more painful

After more than 20 days of the incident, I went to the hospital for treatment

Diagnosed with eyeball loss, choroid rupture

Symptoms such as chronic purulent otitis media in the left ear

And hospitalized for 15 days

The cost of treatment costs more than 10,000 yuan

Appraisal display

Ms. Liu's left eye injury is currently leftover moderate vision damage

Reliable to level 10 disability

After negotiation with Mr. Li's compensation failed

Ms. Liu brought Mr. Li to the court

The claim ordered Mr. Li to compensate for various losses

A total of more than 130,000 yuan

How to judge the court

The court trial considers

Mr. Li's wife requested Ms. Liu

Use bamboo cricket to beat their pears and gifts

Faculty -free good intentions

It reflects the good folk customs of harmony, friendship and integrity of neighbors

The right to be or agreed between the two parties cannot be determined or agreed

Ms. Liu, as a person who has a capable capacity for civil behavior

The danger caused by pear drops should be

Have sufficient cognition and prevent it

Therefore, Ms. Liu's injury

Putting pear with Ms. Huang

There is no causal relationship in the sense of infringement liability

There is no fault to damage the facts

Should not bear the liability for infringement

"Good intentions Shi Hui is a good behavior, which has carried forward a good morality and demonstrated the core values ​​of socialism. In the case of no intentional or major negligence, the good people are required to bear compensation for the loss of beneficiaries. Responsibility should not be supported by the law. "The judge of the trial stated that Ms. Liu's falling pear was injured. It was an unexpected event. It is not good for the good owner to bear the liability for compensation for his damage. Inheriting morality, it is not supported.

Then he decided to reject Ms. Liu's entire claims.

The court's judgment was also praised by netizens

remind:

Nowadays, the season when Guifan is mature

Whether you go to your own garden or elsewhere elsewhere

Pay attention to safety

Avoid accidental damage

Source: CCTV Comprehensive@Western Decision, Polar Meaning News

- END -