In 17 years, she spent 460,000, and a woman in Shanghai asked for half of the support for her husband, and was rejected by the court!

Divorce

How to bear the child's support?

Recently, a news

#17 years spent 460,000

Women's ex -husband is half to be refuted#

Go to Weibo hot search in one fell swoop

Treatment of the attention and hot discussion of the entire network.

Things derived from

Shanghai Jiading District People's Court

Announced case:

Retrospective

The woman Li and the man Xu were divorced by the court in 2004. The daughter lived with the woman, and the man paid 500 yuan to the age of eighteen.

Because the man works abroad all year round, his daughter's education and life are mainly responsible for the plaintiff Li.

Later, the man expressed economic difficulties, and paid the support fee after waiting. The woman applied for forced execution to the court on the issue of support.

At the same time, the woman said,

Paying for daughter for 17 years

Tuition, food fees, tourism fees

A total of more than 460,000 yuan,

The man is required to bear half of it.

From August 2004 to June 2021, the plaintiff Li paid a tuition fee of 185,270 yuan for her daughter Xiaoyu;

Food fees, tourism fees, school uniform fees, accommodation fees, extra -curricular activities, competition courses, competition examination fees, training fees for 142,269 yuan;

With glasses and medical expenses at 84,400 yuan;

The insurance premium was 52,656 yuan, and the total of 464,595 yuan above. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant was half, which is 232,297.50 yuan.

After hearing, the court thought,

Compensation costs exceed the agreement agreement

And the man's consent is not obtained,

It is not necessary to prove that the cost is indeed necessary and reasonable.

For the education and training costs agreed by the divorce agreement after the divorce, the actual support should fulfill the necessary informing obligations. After the other party agrees, if the necessary expenses that fail to negotiate The part of the part should not be included in the burden of support for the non -actual support.

In the end, the court ruled the woman’s request,

At the same time, do not fulfill the man

Criticism of the acting of support for the support fee.

In this case, the cost of the plaintiff's recovery did not make a clear agreement in the divorce mediation letter, and the plaintiff failed to prove that the defendant agreed to bear or the cost was indeed necessary and reasonable. In the end, the court ruled the plaintiff's claim. At the same time, it also criticized the defendant's active active permission to fulfill the obligation to pay for the maintenance fee in accordance with the divorce agreement.

For such a judgment,

Many netizens said they didn't understand,

Even angry! Mind for the woman ~

A netizen said: 500 yuan a month, not even the money for meals, maybe this is why they are unwilling to have children.

Another netizen said: Shouldn't the man pay for the man who does not pay the support fee? How can we simply criticize, isn't this a rogue?

As a single mother,

It is not easy to bring a child to life itself,

Ex -husband should pay the support fee on time

As a result, the children are so old,

The man is actually not paying for 500 yuan

Some netizens bluntly,

Don't kidnap your daughter to support him in the future ~

Mother proposed

In 17 years, it cost 460,000 yuan,

Some netizens calculated a childcare book:

In 17 years, it cost 460,000 yuan in children, with an average of 27,000 a year, and 2,250 yuan per month.

Children's tuition fees, training fees, supplementary courses, buying clothes toys, learning extracurricular books, sick medical treatment, coupled with occasional travel, eating well, 2250 yuan per month is not enough.

Some netizens also speak,

Express the judgment of the court.

"I think the woman has the right to ask the man to compensate back if the woman has not received the raising fee on the agreement in the past 17 years. At that time, the divorce agreement signed at the time stated how much each month was given and how old is it. The child's actual cost in the future must be borne by the woman.

In 500 in 2004, the costs and other costs of nearly ten years were different. At that time, the agreement signed should be stated that it would not lose as a few percentage of wages and other situations. If there is no signing of the income, it can only be given by the conscience of his ex -husband.

In this regard, the court rejected the woman's request on the grounds of exceeding the divorce agreement, etc., and I personally understand it! After all, there is no way to follow the agreement, white paper and black. Criticizing the act of not fulfilling the obligations of the support for the maintenance fee, I think it is not just criticism, but it should also be charged. To be honest, it ’s really not much to spend hundreds of thousands of children when I came out to society. "

Some netizens suggest that the woman

You can prosecute the increase in support.

This made Xiao Nong think of

There is also a similar news last year-

Men's Shanghai has 4 houses, graduated from famous universities, and has an annual salary of 500,000. After the divorce, he only gives his ex -wife and daughter for 600 yuan. After his wife filed an appeal, the Shanghai No. 1 Intermediate Court renovated: pay 2,000 yuan a month for support.

Wang Yinyi, a lawyer of Shanghai Maritime Law Firm, said: It is really difficult to get a high support fee through the court's decision. Although the cost of raising baby in first -tier cities such as Shanghai is an indisputable fact, the court's judgment standard is to consider the life of ordinary people.The level is not the living standard of the middle class, nor is it the level of "chicken baby competition"."Law is the minimum morality, so the support for raising is also the minimum guarantee. Whether parents can pay for their children is love, not the law." Anyway, what does

As a man, there should be a responsibility,

After all, it is also his own child.

How can I even pay 500 yuan?

I wonder if there are other hidden feelings?

What do you think about this?

【Tian Xiaoyu Comprehensive Edit】

Material source: @ @ @ @来 来 Please contact.

- END -