My sister refused to buy a house for her brother, and was sued by the parents to ask for 500,000 to raise money

I refused to buy a house for my brother

As a result, his parents were sued in the court ...

Today (12)

"My sister refused to buy a house for my brother and was sued by his parents."

Causedive heated discussion

↓↓↓

According to "Guangzhou Pu" news

29 -year -old Ms. Zhang has been 2 years old

He was sent to his aunt's house by his parents

later

Because the economic conditions are not good

Parents have never picked up Ms. Zhang back

The years when I live in my aunt

Ms. Zhang was sensible early

From childhood life experience

Make her particularly strong and brave

Because I grew up in my aunt's house since I was a child

So Ms. Zhang

Always have a strange feeling for parents

She rarely contacted her parents, and her parents rarely contacted her

I thought the two sides would always maintain this state

After many years

Ms. Zhang's career is successful

So I bought a room for my cousin of my aunt's house

His parents think

Ms. Zhang bought a house for my cousin

Then she should also buy a house for her brother

Ms. Zhang also made clear statements

I won't pay for my brother to buy a house

after

The contradiction between Ms. Zhang and her parents is becoming more and more serious

Until the parents told her to court

Ask 500,000 maintenance

Ms. Zhang thinks

I have never been "raised" by my parents

It should not be reported to "raising the grace"

Plaintiff: adult children should support their parents

Paying 500,000 yuan for maintenance is reasonable

The plaintiff's agent stated that the Civil Code stipulates that adult children have the obligation to support their parents. Children's support for their parents is unconditional. It is not eliminated for any reason. Children cannot choose whether to support their parents with their own relatives and evils for their parents.

In judicial practice, the maintenance of maintenance is generally determined according to the standards of 20%to 30%of children's income. The defendant is now 29 years old. He has not paid maintenance in the past ten years. According to the defendant's wage income level, he paid 50,000 yuan a year as alimony, and 500,000 yuan belongs to a one -time paid for maintenance, which is reasonable.

Defendant: My sister has no obligation to raise her brother

The defendant's agent said that in law, the sister did not have the obligation to raise her brother, unless the parents died or were unable to raise it, and the younger brother was a special circumstances of the minor. But in this case, my brother is an adult.

According to the "Civil Code", parents who lack labor ability or difficulty in life do have the right to require adult children to pay for maintenance. Essence

Court judgment: How much to pay for it

Can be agreed as appropriate

The judge said that the plaintiff was older, and the defendant, as his child, had the obligation to support his parents. However, as an adult, the plaintiff should not add the pressure of buying a house to the defendant in the name of supporting and supporting.

The plaintiff had a pension income enough to enjoy his old age, and the defendant was adopted by his aunt since he was a child. The plaintiff did not fulfill the obligation of his parents. The maintenance of the defendant's required maintenance should be agreed in accordance with the actual situation of the defendant and the plaintiff as appropriate.

What do you think?

Comprehensive: Guangzhou Judicial Bureau, if there is any infringement, please contact this public account.

- END -