The suspected Nanjing Massacre photos have caused attention to the industry experts: regardless of the identification results, the significance is far beyond the photo itself

↑ There is a photo in the photo album that Kyle exposed to the text "Hello on Nanking Road" (Nanjing Road Hell)

Red Star Journalist ｜ Luo Mengjie Wang Yuji Intern ｜ Li Ying

Edit ｜ Guan Li Pan Li

Recently, a foreign -style shop owner posted on the social platform that he received a photo album that was suspected of being related to the Nanjing Massacre, and then posted a number of war photos in the album. The topic has aroused the attention of the entire network. Soon, a well -known historical blogger in China also said through the Internet that there is a similar album in their hands, and its materials and covers are very similar, and even the tragedies recorded in many photos in it are the same. However, the blogger said: "There is no scene in the album in my hand about the Nanjing Massacre. I am not sure if the album in the owner of the foreign shop is available."

The blogger also said that regardless of the results of the photos, foreign shop owners can expose the matter, let more people know and understand the Nanjing Massacre, which has far exceeded the photo itself.

Regarding whether the photo records the scene of the Nanjing Massacre, Cui Wei, a researcher at the Institute of History of the School of Social Sciences and the Nanjing Folk Anti -Japanese War History Museum, told Hongxing News that it is difficult to determine whether the relevant photos are currently from the Internet to determine whether the relevant photos are Nanjing University The photos of the slaughter period need to be further identified in conjunction with several experts in the Nanjing Massacre Memorial. The Memorial Hall of the Nanjing Massacre of the Nanjing Massacre of China said through official Weibo that the relevant information will be verified.

↑ There is a picture of "Ling Chi to death" in the album that Kyle is exposed to

New evidence of the Nanjing Massacre exposed abroad?

Ceremony Memorial Hall response: The relevant information will be verified

On September 1st, Evan Kyle, the owner of the pawn shop of Mingni Plus, the United States, released a video on a social platform that he received a photo album for World War II sold by a client, saying that it contained more than 30 suspecteds to be Nanjing. Photos of the Massacre of the Massacre. Subsequently, Kyle took a number of photos suspected of the Nanjing Massacre on social platforms with videos or tweets. For a while, related topics such as "suspected new evidence of the Nanjing Massacre" attracted the attention of the entire network.

By looking at the photo album photos on the social platform, the Red Star reporters saw that some of these photos showed Ling Chi for execution, the miserable women and children who were killed by bombs, and portraits of some times. In addition, Red Star reporters also noticed that Kyle once mentioned that he found a name named Leslie Allen in the album. According to netizens, this person may be an American soldier who died in 1964. Therefore, Kyle believes that this Leslie Allen may be the photographer of the photo.

↑ Kyle's related dynamics in his social account update event

On September 2nd, Kyle spoke through social media, saying that the museum was the only destination for the museum with customers, and the album would not be handed over to the Japanese government. Soon, it sounded again, saying that experts had sought experts to identify authenticity, but identification was not a fast process, and it took about a month or two. The album has also been sent elsewhere and cannot be displayed to the public. "Sending part of the album to the Internet is to hope that more people can understand the cruelty of the war."

It is reported that shortly after the incident caused public opinion, the Japanese invading Japanese Nanjing Massacre Memorial Memorial Hall said through official Weibo that it has paid attention to this information and is now trying to contact the other party to verify the relevant information. On September 5th, the Red Star reporter contacted a staff member of the Memorial Hall of the Ninjun Massacre of the Nanjing Massacre of the Nanjing Massacre of the Japanese Army, saying that it was not clear about the latest progress of the incident.

Domestic bloggers say they have similar albums

But there is no scene of the Nanjing Massacre

Just as many netizens discussed the photos of Kyle, on the evening of September 2, the vibrato user "Zou Dehuai's old photo" updated a video online, saying that there was a similar album in his hand, which contained about 400 400 inside The photos of Zhang during World War II, but according to it, the content of the contents inside has not yet been found related to the Nanjing Massacre.

↑ Zou Dehuai's album is exactly the same tragedy photo as the Kyle album

Zou Dehuai told the Red Star News reporter that he is a photo collection enthusiast and especially likes to collect photos of the Anti -Japanese War. He often shares his collections to the Internet. Therefore, after this matter is exposed, many netizens come to compare him in private. Identification. After carefully looking at the photos of Kyle, he accidentally found that he received a photo album received from the private collectors from Oregon on July 26, 2016, which was similar to its height.

"The materials and covers of the album are very similar, and even the tragedy recorded in many photos in it is the same." Zou Dehuai said that according to its understanding, such albums mainly appeared in Peiping, Tianjin, Qingdao, Shanghai and other places at the time. It belongs to the type of private customization. The merchant mainly provides the style of the album cover. The contents of the inside are added by the buyer. The owner of the album in my hand and the album in Kyle may happen to choose the leather cover. "

↑ This photo in Zou Dehuai has also appeared in the Kyle album

When talking about whether the photo photo of the netizens cared about is the Nanjing Massacre scene, Zou Dehuai said that the most representative point is the text next to Kyle with a text "Hell on Nanking Road (Note: Nanjing Road Hell ) "," I think Kyle should be misjudgment, because the album in my hand also has an exactly the same photo, and there are many other angles in my album, a total of 5 photos, mainly showing 1937 8 in 1937 The scene where the Yuehashi company was bombed by the Japanese army, and the place of this bombardment happened to be Nanjing Road in Shanghai. "The explanation given by Zou Dehuai for why the two privately customized albums would have the same photo was that many major major at that time were many major majority at that time. The photos of the incident were rinsed out in batches by the vendors, and sold it to tourists and officers and soldiers who came to China like postcards. These buyers will put these photos in their own albums as souvenirs. "Just like this album in my hand, the original owner has a good habit. He likes to write some annotations on the photo, like a diary or essay." Zou Dehuai said that the owner of the album in his hand is Seibold. Sailor has always been patrolling in the Yangtze River field. The album that it owns completely records the entire process from mid -1937 to the end of the year, that is, starting from the Three Gorges, arriving in Nanjing along the river, and then arriving in Nanjing in July and August, and finally going to Shanghai.

"During the process, Seibold took a lot of photos by himself. Some Japanese army bombed Chinese ships, bombarded the Shimonatsu of Nanjing, and Pukou Wharf. He even put the briefing on the day in it, especially serious." Zou Dehuai told reporters that he was in the reporter that he was in Kyle's photo album photos also saw some details, which preliminarily judged its owner or a sailor of a sea fleet as the US Navy.

↑ Zou Dehuai provides photos of the tragedy of the company in his hands

Expert analysis:

No matter whether the photo is a massacre scene

Its meaning is far beyond the photo itself

Is the photo album in Kyle's hands of the scene of the Nanjing Massacre, and how to identify the authenticity? Zou Dehuai said that whether a photo is an old photo is actually very identified and can start with its material naturally. However, it is not easy to determine whether the content of a photo is in line with related historical kissing. It not only needs a lot of historical documents to confirm it, but also combines the historical data of other countries to confirm it. I want to thank him all the scenes of the slaughter. Because he exposed this matter, many foreigners knew the Nanjing Massacre for the first time, and the significance was far more than the photo itself. "

In addition, Cui Wei, a special adviser to the History of the History of the Nanjing Folk Anti -Japanese War History Museum of the History of the Nanjing Folk Anti -Japanese War History Museum, also said that the photos of Kyle in the hands of the Nanjing Massacre of the Nanjing Massacre of the Nanjing Massacre of the History Researcher at the History of the Institute of History of the Nanjing Folk Anti -Japanese War in the Jiangsu Provincial Academy of Social Sciences also said The photos of the Nanjing Massacre need to be further identified with several experts.

↑ There is a picture of "Women Participating in Fighting" in the albums of Kyle

Cui Wei told the Red Star Journalist that during the Holocaust, the Japanese command department prohibited the Japanese officers and soldiers' shooting to save the Japanese atrocities of the Japanese army. Therefore, the current historical materials of the Nanjing Massacre are rarely seen in the historical materials of the Japanese army. Most of the limited image materials currently preserved were taken by Western people or Japanese reporters who stayed in Nanjing. "If the photo is indeed a massacre period, To shoot, you also need to further determine the specific source of the photo. In general, from another aspect (where the American Westerners) once again confirm the authenticity of the Nanjing Massacre and the cruelty of the Japanese invasion of China. The forces attempts to deny the Nanjing Massacre, negate the non -righteous lies of the war of aggression against China, and add empirical to our patriotic education. "

At the same time, Sun Zhawei, a researcher at the Jiangsu Academy of Social Sciences and the Nanjing Massacre Research Association of the Japanese Invasion, also said in an interview with the media that the photos that can be seen at present can not determine whether its location is in Nanjing. Whether the photo is during the Nanjing Massacre, there are three key points. First of all, from time to time, the season should be winter; secondly, there is a place with obvious characteristics of Nanjing; finally, it is necessary to support text and literature. "

-End

- END -