Doctoral dissertation copy Baidu Encyclopedia?Author's response: "Everything is in line with academic norms"

Author:Scientific network Time:2022.09.03

Wen | Meng Lingxiao

Following the former mayor of Hsinchu City and former Taoyuan Mayor Lin Zhijian's thesis copied the storm, Cai Yong, the candidate of the Democratic Progressive Party Keelung, was also exposed to the doctoral dissertation published at the "Urban Planning Institute" at Taipei University. Plagiarism.

On September 1, Taipei City Public Opinion representatives Liu Shijie, Chen Zhiming, and Jiang Xinyi, a member of the Keelung City Councilor, held a press conference to announce the details of the plagiarism of Cai Yiyi. It is said that Cai Ying's doctoral dissertation concludes that the proportion of plagiarism is as high as 33%, and the content is even copied Wikipedia and Baidu Encyclopedia.

In response, Cai adapt to the response, "My paper is inspected by plagiarizing the system through the paper, and everything is in line with academic norms." He said that because of his leadership, his opponent deliberately attacked him with the paper.

Taipei University stated that on the morning of September 2, the relevant reporting information was received, and the case was moved to the relationship office, and the review committee was established in accordance with regulations. Decide.

Photo source: Cai Yiying social media

Three major issues, point directly to "mosaic plagiarism"

While running for the mayor of Keelung, Cai adapted to the ads of the ads to the admission and scored academic qualifications as "Dr. Metropolitan Plan".

According to the website of the Taiwan Martial Arts Paper Knowledge value value -added system, Cai Yiying's doctoral thesis on October 25, 2019 at Taipei University entitled "Globalization, Terminal Governance of Harbor City -Taking Keelung as an example", the total number of words exceeded 13 Thousands of characters, 220 pages in length.

At a press conference on September 1st, Liu Shijie and others stated that after page comparison, they found that there were three major issues in the paper, namely the papers plagiarized 30 documents, of which 25 were not included in the reference; the proportion of plagiarism was as high as 33 33 %; Content even copied Wikipedia and Baidu Encyclopedia.

刘仕杰表示，论文内居然出现逐字抄录百度百科、维基百科的内容，论文第2页全页字数903字，竟有493字抄袭百度百科，抄袭比例达55%；第60页全页527字， The number of words of Plagiarism of Wikipedia is 468 words, and the proportion of plagiarism is 89%; the proportion of Plagiarism of Wikipedia on page 65 is still as high as 59%.

Chen Zhiming said that such a "mosaic plagiarism" method of "mosaic plagiarism" could not be written like this. Can a doctoral dissertation be written like this?

Jiang Xinyi, a candidate for Keelung City Council, believes that Cai Yiyi, as the mayor of Keelung, has serious flaws in academic ethics and integrity. How can the Keelung people believe him? Cai Yong should make it clear, do not use political language at will to avoid the people's review.

In addition, some netizens believe that Cai Yiyi's PhD thesis guidance professor in this plagiarism is difficult to blame. According to the website of the Taipei University Municipal Planning Research Institute, Cai's adaptive professor is Zhou Zhilong, who was a professor and director of the Taipei University Municipal Planning Research Institute, and currently served as a honorary professor at Taipei University.

Huang Yangming, a senior media person in Taiwan, pointed out that Cai Zhilong's guidance professor Zhou Zhilong, during the guidance period and oral test time, has structural problems. "This itself is ridiculous. Legislative and examination members are check -in in power, because legislators can supervise the examination institute, but the examination members have become teachers."

In response, Cai Yiyi responded in social media that he worshiped under Zhou Zhilong in 2009. "I did not expect that the teacher would become an examination committee member and I can choose a legislator."

In response to the quality of the dissertation, Cai Yiyi said, "There are more than 300 original literature, but later because of the overall content, there are several places that missed references, deleted to more than 260 strokes, and the proportion of a single reference was only only referenced. 2%, no more than 4%of academic standards. "

Cai adaptive thesis comparison "color duty" picture source: Liu Shijie social media

In order to win the voting, the high school education is also faked?

In August of this year, Cai Yiyi was involved in the "pseudo -high school education" storm.

Many people questioned that Cai was adapted to Keelung High School who was not in the election place, but for a long time, he used the "pseudo -high school education" to fight for Keelung's voter identity.

In response to this, Luo Zhiqiang, a former Taipei City Councilor, said in social media that Lin Zhijian did not hesitate to copy the papers in order to cheat a master's degree. I did not expect that Cai was adapted to now. He revealed that because the school has adapted Cai as an outstanding alumni for many years, and as a genuine alumni, he always thought that the other party was a schoolman. He could not think that he was actually a fake alumni, which was dumbfounded.

However, Cai adapt to response. In his personal official documents or election bulletin, he never wrote Keelung High School to graduate. However, because of long -term efforts and dedication in the local area, he has participated in the alumni meeting. He said that the alumni association and graduation were two different things, and it was very strange to be confused.

In this regard, Luo Zhiqiang, a "genuine alumni", said that his statement was close to "I just don't deny it for 16 years, pretending to be me", and she criticized Cai to adapt to the hidden identity, associated with the locals, and had no integrity at all.

Public information shows that Cai's master's and doctoral dissertations are related to Keelung City, a doctoral dissertation. His master's graduation thesis at Tamkang University entitled "Research on Urban Development Strategy under Globalization -Taking Keelung City as an example", and the doctoral dissertation at Taipei University entitled "Globalization, the space -level governance of the harbor cities -Yinglong For example, ".

On the morning of September 2nd, Cai Yiyi conducted a live "papers open" in social media, saying that the policy he advocated was the content integration of doctoral research experience over the past ten years. Its doctoral dissertation Abstract shows that for the analysis of the field survey cases of Keelung, this study pointed out that the key to the transformation and change of port cities in the process of globalization mainly determines the governance of multi -scale political and economic strategy governance in the region, between regions, and regions. influences. Some netizens commented that from the "pseudo -high school degree" to the layout of Shuobo papers, it can be described as a "big chess" that voters recognized by voters in the Keelung area.

Taiwan Media Review: Comparison education has become a atmosphere

Recently, the papers in Taiwan have been frequent.

Since Cai adapts to plagiarism, many netizens have called it "Lin Zhijian Second" and "Xiaozhi's good friends" in Cai Yi's social media reviews, implying that Cai's doctoral dissertation is suspected of plagiarism. It is exactly the same as that of the DPP Mayor Lin Zhijian's master's dissertation.

In July of this year, Lin Zhijian was suspected of plagiarism in Taiwan University in 2017 and published in Taiwan University in Taiwan and 2008 at the Chinese University of Taiwan. While Lin Zhijian emphasized that he was a "victim", the two universities announced their decisions on August 9 and August 24 after the academic ethics survey and revoked their master's degree.

At present, Lin Zhijian has announced his withdrawal from the mayor of Taoyuan, saying that he would defend his "innocence" in another battlefield. He wrote on social media, "Because my personal hard work and defects of writing have impacted the quiet campus of the National Taiwan University and the University of China, and even the review system caused everyone to tear. ","

It is worth mentioning that after Lin Zhijian's withdrawal from the election, Cai Yiyi was "very small". He said that although Lin Zhijian has the storm of the paper, Lin's governance performance in the past in Hsinchu was still worthy of recognition. Will continue to support Lin's insistence on academic papers.

In the morning of September 2nd, Cai adapt to the live broadcast of the "Thesis Uniform", and he mentioned that the main axis of his doctoral dissertation was combined with academic theory and local empirical evidence. Coincidentally, Lin Zhijian's two master's dissertations are also based on local empirical evidence.

For the essays that have been frequently produced in Taiwan in recent years, China Times News Network previously commented that there is a atmosphere of politicians in the island to compare their academic qualifications: those who have studied in college, they try to get a master's degree; if they have a master's degree, find a way to find a way You have to get a doctorate. The local doctoral doctors are not bluffed enough. Most of the pheasant universities in Mei and British are that as long as they have money, they do not have to know English. What about the paper? Either spend money to find someone to write, or to move and move.

At 14:00 on September 2nd, Cai Yiyi said in social media that the paper was not perfect, but it was definitely a test. I don't mind the opponent's suppression, and I am also willing to accept the censorship of the Taipei University Xuelun Association (Note: Academic Ethics Review Committee).

Reference materials:

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/1d_ggcj9sue8ol7yc36oqg

https://mp.weixin.qq.com/s/ygmvrtwahu5cFRM_3DQBGG

Edit | Fangyuan

Capture | Zhihai