Sky H5 Comparison Dangbei X3 Experience: Can LED projection counterattack laser projection?

Author:Cicilab Time:2022.09.28

Foreword

Dangbei X3 was released for more than a year. This telephoto laser light source has obtained market attention with its strong brightness, but to this day, there is almost no follow -up in the industry, and it is still unique in the DLP projector.

The H -series flagship officially released in August 2022, which was officially released in August 2022, not only increased the update in terms of products, but also announced a new CCB luminous standard. The standard of the National Standard Society (ANSI) that has not been changed for decades.

Dangbei X3 has attracted much attention because of the laser light source that refreshed the upper limit of DLP's projection brightness; as a latecomer, the XGIMI H5 officially announced the first bomb of self -developed light machines. No accidents will cause many consumers to choose difficulties due to the close price.

This article will compare XGIMI H5 and Dangbei X3 from multiple angles, hoping to provide some help to you who choose between the two.

Design difference

Both the XGIMI H5 and Dangbei X3 are designed by their respective family. The difference between the two alone is still quite different. The H5 as a whole is more rounded, and the X3 is more square. Of course, from the perspective of length, width, and height, H5 is a circle smaller than X3 and is more compact.

The H5 uses a hidden interface design, so that the exposed interface can not be seen directly from the back, and it is more visually integrated. The interface design of the X3 is relatively traditional. If there is a need to place the wall, at least the distance of the power cord is required.

The interface types of H5 and X3 remain the same.

At the top design, H5 uses a depression design, leaving only a physical power button; X3 uses a touch switch and continues the 4 function keys above. It can be seen from the materials on the top that H5 uses sandblasting process and X3 uses glass.

The above is the difference between the two in terms of appearance. Cicilab has avoiding the discussion of subjective preferences as much as possible. After all, everyone's aesthetics are different, retaining their favorite.

Comparison

The most concerned about the projection is the "audio and video" ability. The quality of the picture is the existence of all users the most. I also avoid obscure content below. It is clear to everyone with a simple and easy -to -understand contrast.

List the factors that affect the quality:

Light source: H5 uses LED light sources, X3 uses laser light source;

system version:

The test is completed under the standard brightness of the two:

Brightness contrast

First look at the comparison between the two products under the standard brightness. The comparison in this regard is mainly to look at the top products of XGIMI H5 as the top product of LED light sources. Whether it can have a natural advantage in the light source brightness itself.

First read the same pure white picture comparison brightness, the test point is the four corners. Control the variable method. The distance between the two machines is equal to the wall, and the air pressure, humidity, and temperature of the test space are equally conditions.

The order of data is: upper left, lower left, upper right, lower right, central (unit LUX).

Under the default ordinary brightness mode:

XGIMI: 2043, 2658, 2270, 2954, 3236;

Dangbei X3: 2898, 3372, 2561, 3043, 3541.

Of course, I believe that many viewers are interested in the "contrast of brightness" and will the maximum brightness mode of the two machines.

XGR H5: 2143, 2760, 2336, 3152, 3364;

Dangbei X3: 3192, 3854, 2910, 3414, 4011;

It can be seen that in the white field of the same standard brightness, the brightness of the Beibei X3 is higher, and the advantages of laser light sources still exist. But in the default mode, the central brightness of XGIMI H5 is very close to Dangbei X3, which is a more interesting signal.

The final brightness of the picture is not only the cause of the "light source". The light transmission capacity of the lens, the optimization of the light path, the design of the light machine, and the heat dissipation capacity of the whole machine will all affect the final brightness. Of course, only testing in the white field will also have different brightness effects. Relatively speaking, by changing the color temperature and adjusting the color, it can also help the white field brightness. Only the brightness test of the white field may only represent the so -called nominal brightness, and the user is often rich in color movies, variety shows, etc. When watching it, the next section will test the color brightness.

However, from the current development and application scenarios of the industry, the brightness of the flagship DLP projector is no longer the pain point of "bedroom solution". Most people are more willing to use products with "automatic brightness adjustment". Dangbei X3 has this function. The update of H5 in the "Environmental Light Adaptation" function is noticed: that is, only adjusting the brightness, but not changing the color temperature, because the brightness of XGIMI for different gears has been calibrated. But if there is no such control, many projection will be yellow when the projection is dark, and it will be colored. If you have a projection in your family, you can also try to observe whether the color changes when you adjust the brightness.

If it is just pursuing brightness, the opportunity of light bulbs is greater than LED, but the bulb machine is destined to be eliminated in the home field, which also illustrates this from the side -the brightness is the basis, but not all. Color contrast

All the colors we can see in the projection are "red", "green", "blue" of different proportion

The three primary colors of light are red, green, and blue. Through the comparison of the three, with some high -definition patterns, we can easily see the difference.

Why do you care about color? Because the initial purpose of our purchase of projection is to watch videos (or pictures). A large part of the "observation" we often say is composed of color. The better the color performance, the better the movie viewing experience. Compare complex pictures later.

First look at the main green color, and the two can hardly see the difference in the photo.

Red contrast, of which the Green value of the Beibei X3 is high, when the naked eye is directly seen, it is "orange".

The disadvantages of monochrome lasers have begun to appear, and red laser is very difficult to grasp. This is a problem in the industry.

Pure blue comparison, it is difficult to see the difference between the two.

Comparison of landscape maps, this is a set of maple leaves, but under the contrast, it is found that Dangbei X3 can no longer see "red leaves", and when the naked eye is directly seen, the bell cannot show the pure red.

The difference between the two in the landscape of blue -green is not obvious.

In the dark tone scene, the gap between the two on the color is also difficult to detect. However, when the Beibei X3 appears, there is a color -oriented fault (please zoom in the picture), and the picture above is quite obvious.

Looking at portraits, the face of Beibei X3 is whiter in comparison, and the XGIMI H5 is relatively bloody. But it is not a simple white balance tendency, we look down.

Choose a portrait with a background as a green portrait. You can see that the overall performance of XGIMI H5 is better (skin color). When the shell X3 is green, you can see the green vegetation in the background. The performance of the rice H5 in red and green color saturation and brightness is better than Dangbei X3.

It can be clearly seen that Dangbei X3 has a monochrome laser, which causes the color gamut lack. It is easy to "have no blood" in the close -up of the characters, not normal colors.

In terms of color performance, XGIMI H5 hammered Dangbei X3 into a slag. When the monochrome laser of the Beibei X3 chose to take care of the brightness, most consumers in the market had no conditions for comparison and were easily deceived.

Automatic trapezoidal correction comparison

Most people use household projectors with stents, which will inevitably occur, so a good and reliable automatic trapezoidal is very necessary.

First look at the ability of XGIMI H5, upgrade the trapezoidal correction function of H3S, and use the ability of 3D TOF to greatly improve the correction speed and accuracy, so as to not use correction auxiliary pictures while further shortening the correction time.

When the Beibei X3 still needs to correct the auxiliary chart and the focusing auxiliary chart for assistance, it is a state of interruption in experience in experience.

The "automatic trapezoidal correction" of the two models has the advanced derivative function of "automatic obstacle avoidance", but the difference in effect is still relatively large. For details, please refer to the following comparison.

First look at the intelligent obstacle avoidance of XGIMI H5, which can easily identify the obstacles on the wall and avoid it through the mobile screen. It does not require users to adjust it by themselves.

In contrast, Dangbei X3 cannot recognize the obstacles on the wall at all.

Eye protection ability comparison

Because of the soft furnishing transformation, most people's household plans will not choose to hang up. Many people are worried about the strong light shot on the eyes of strong light, especially for users who have children at home. Compared.

The XGIMI H5 achieves a large -scale space modeling through the 3D TOF function. Compared with the previous generation of products, it can accurately recognize the head of the character and achieve light avoidance for the head.

When the Beibei X3 uses a Xiemi solution similar to the previous generation. TOF recognizes that the full screen will diminish when people pass by, and the actual performance performance response speed and accuracy are relatively poor.

Sound effect comparison

What is more interesting is that both have DTS HD and Dobby Audio certification, but the comparative sense can be said to be different.

Pcked with Harman for many years, H5 still uses the original speaker, and the effect of sound quality has easily reached the qualification level of ordinary home speakers.

When the Beibei X3 is in comparison, it is sad and dived at low frequencies. There are some harsh sounds at high frequencies, sorry for the so -called "viper sound effects".

Summarize

Back to the product itself, the comparison between the two believes that everyone has understood the product power of the two products.

Comparison of X3 X3, X3, in addition to pure white and pure green brightness, is more advantageous, XGIMI H5 is comprehensive in comprehensive display effect, eye protection ability, and sound effect.

Of course, after all, Dangbei X3 has been released for more than a year, and the advantages of the Sky H5 have the advantages of time. The completely self -developed light machine allows it to reach higher brightness in LED light sources, and The new chapter also ushered in.

It is worth noting that Dangbe X3 propagates that he is up to 3200 ANSI. It is undoubtedly very high water, but the tolerance of the industry is relatively high (allowing 20%error value), resulting in many brands "to go high to high to highPropaganda, I hope everyone will be considered.Although Dangbe X3 has an advantage in the same type of brightness in terms of brightness, it also sacrifices color performance because of the use of this high -cost light source, which is a lot of money.